|

MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATION MEMORANDUM
Office of Inspector General, Licensing Division
Public Information
Minnesota Statutes, section 626.557, subdivision 1 states, “The legislature declares that the public policy of this state is to protect adults who, because of physical or mental disability or dependency on institutional services, are particularly vulnerable to maltreatment.”
Report Number: 202302535 | Date Issued: August 30, 2023 |
Name and Address of Facility Investigated: Beacon Specialized Living Shakopee
1075 Shakopee Ave E.
Shakopee, MN 55379
Beacon Specialized Living
1355 Mendota Heights Rd.
Suite 260
Mendota Heights, MN 55120 | Disposition: Allegation One: Inconclusive Allegation Two: Inconclusive Allegation Three: False |
| | |
License Number and Program Type:
1113760-H_CRS (Home and Community-Based Services-Community Residential Setting)
1070450-HCBS (Home and Community-Based Services)
Investigator(s):
Danielle Morrison
Minnesota Department of Human Services
Office of Inspector General
Licensing Division
PO Box 64242
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55164-0242
danielle.morrison@state.mn.us 651-431-5647
Suspected Maltreatment Reported:
Allegation One: It was reported that a vulnerable adult (VA) hit his/her head on a doorframe causing a laceration to the VA’s right eyebrow. It was reported that staff persons (SP1, SP2, and SP3) hit the VA. The VA also had bruising on his/her arm.
Allegation Two: It was reported that SP1 took money from the VA and other clients at the facility.
Allegation Three: It was reported that staff persons allowed facility clients (C1 and C2) to hit the VA.
Date of Incident(s): On going prior to March 25, 2023
Nature of Alleged Maltreatment Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 626.557, subdivision 9c, paragraph (b), and Minnesota Statutes, section 626.5572, subdivision 15, and subdivision 2, paragraph (b), clause (1); and subdivision 9, paragraph (b), clause (1); and subdivision 17, paragraph (a):
Conduct which is not an accident or therapeutic conduct which produces or could reasonably be expected to produce physical pain or injury or emotional distress including, but not limited to: hitting, slapping, kicking, pinching, biting, or corporal punishment of a vulnerable adult.
In the absence of legal authority, a person willfully uses, withholds, or disposes of funds or property of a vulnerable adult.
The failure or omission by a caregiver to supply a vulnerable adult with care or services, including but not limited to food, clothing, shelter, health care, or supervision which is reasonable and necessary to obtain or maintain the vulnerable adult's physical or mental health or safety, considering the physical and mental capacity or dysfunction of the vulnerable adult and which is not the result of an accident or therapeutic conduct.
Summary of Findings: Pertinent information was obtained during a site visit conducted on April 7, 2023; from documentation at the facility; and through seven interviews conducted with one supervisory staff person (P1), SP1, SP2, three facility staff persons (P2-P4), and the VA’s guardian (G).
This investigator reached out to SP3 by telephone and mail to request an interview but SP3 did not respond.
On a main floor of the facility there was a living room, a dining room, and a kitchen. Down a hallway from the main space was a bathroom, and two bedrooms including the VA’s. On the lower level there was an additional living room, an office, a bathroom, and two more bedrooms.
The VA’s diagnoses included autism and a severe intellectual disability. The VA had limited verbal communication skills. The VA enjoyed going to Target and getting coffee at Caribou.
The VA’s Coordinated Services and Supports Plan (CSSP) stated that “[the VA] may become physically aggressive towards others.” The VA’s Individual Abuse Prevention Plan (IAPP) stated that the VA did not “have a comprehension of personal space and what can be considered inappropriate touching.” “Staff persons will be educated of this and trained how to be progressive to set appropriate boundaries with [the VA] without angering [the VA].”
Allegation One: It was reported that the VA hit his/her head on a doorframe causing a laceration to the VA’s right eyebrow. It was also reported that SP1, SP2, and SP3 hit the VA. The VA also had bruising on his/her arm.
The facility’s Incident Report stated that on March 18, 2023, around noon, the VA was running in the facility and when running to go to his/her room, the VA hit his/her left eyebrow on the doorframe causing an injury. Staff persons notified P1 and the G. Staff persons cleaned the wound and the bleeding stopped before the G came to pick the VA up to bring him/her to the hospital. The VA was sent home the same day with no stiches and a topical ointment to apply to the wound.
The G provided the following information:
· SP1 “FaceTimed” the G when the VA split open his/her eyebrow. SP1 stated that the VA was upset, asking for the G, and hit his/her head on the doorframe. The G took the VA to the hospital and at first the doctor was going to use stitches, but then decided not to due to the VA’s disability and not wanting to put the VA under sedation just for stitches.
· The G then heard from P2 that the VA grabbed a drink from someone and ran down the hallway to the room and ran into the doorframe.
· On March 25, 2023, the G picked up the VA and it was a warmer day, so the G took off the VA’s long-sleeved shirt and noticed bruising on the VA’s arm. The G took a video of bruises the VA had on his/her upper arm that looked like four fingerprints and sent it to P1.
· The G was concerned based on the “discrepancy” between what s/he was told by SP1 and P2, the bruises on the VA, and a high turnover of staffing within the facility. The VA was not verbal and was not able to tell the G what was going on.
Photographs from the G showed a laceration to the VA’s right eyebrow approximately ½ inch in length.
This investigator reviewed the video the G sent to P1 showing bruising on the VA. This investigator saw a scratch about an inch long on the back of VA’s right upper arm. There were also two faint bruises, one above the scratch and one below. On the VA’s left arm there were some scabs and three “fingerprint” sized bruises ranging in colors of purple and yellow.
P4 provided the following information:
· P4 was not working the day that the VA hurt his/her eyebrow, but the next time P4 worked, s/he saw a paper with a body chart on it for staff persons to document bruising. SP2 told P4 it was because the G was “suspicious” of how the VA got hurt. P4 stated that SP1 told P4 that SP1 hit the VA and lied about how the VA got hurt. P4 stated that the G was told that the VA fell out of the shower.
· When the VA came home from school, sometimes the VA hit staff persons because the VA did not speak so s/he tried other ways to communicate with staff persons and the staff persons were on their phones, so the VA hit them, and several staff persons hit the VA back. P4 asked SP3 why s/he hit the VA, and SP3 responded to P4 that s/he was not going to let the VA hit him/her. SP1 told P4 to just hit the VA back if s/he was hit by the VA. P4 said SP2 had also hit the VA. P4 did not provide any details regarding specific incidents.
· P4 saw two bruises on the VA’s lower right arm that were reddish, and purple in color. At first P4 thought this was normal for the VA, but then realized these were “from the staff [persons].” P4 said the VA had scratches on his/her legs and on his/her stomach.
· P4 told this investigator that s/he worked with SP1 “almost every day,” however, facility documentation did not show P4 listed on the staff schedule to work with SP1. When speaking of SP3, P4 stated that SP3 was a person of a different gender than SP3 was. This investigator reached out to P4 by several means for clarification and further details about the information s/he initially provided, and P4 did not respond to those attempts.
P3 provided the following information:
· The incident occurred on a Saturday and the VA wanted to go to school, but s/he did not have school that day, so the VA wanted coffee. P3 took the VA to get coffee and on the way back called SP1 to see if s/he wanted something to eat. P3 stated s/he went back to the facility, put the VA’s money back in the pouch downstairs, and then went and sat on one side of the table with SP1 across from P2. The VA was running along the hallway. The VA tried to grab SP1’s drink and SP1 told the VA s/he could not have it, so SP1 walked with the VA to his/her bedroom to “take a break.” The VA was in his/her room and SP1 went back to the table. Then, the VA came out, locked his/her bedroom door, and went back to the table. SP1 went and unlocked the VA’s bedroom door. As SP1 was walking back to the table, the VA went back to his/her bedroom so they passed each other in the hallway. Then, SP1 returned to the table. P3 was also sitting at the table and shortly after SP1 returned, the VA came back out of his/her room and the VA was crying. The VA had a little blanket over his/her head, and P3 asked P2, “What is wrong with [the VA]?” Then the VA moved the blanket and the staff persons noticed blood by the VA’s eye, so they got up and administered first aid.
· P3 did not know how the VA injured his/her eyebrow. P3 stated that in the past the VA has hit his/her head on the wall and scratched him/herself. P3 said SP1 did not know what happened either, but they needed to fill out a report and call the G because they thought the VA needed stitches. The G came and took the VA to the doctor. P3 was not at the facility when the VA returned.
· At times, the VA tried to hit people. Staff persons had a pad to hold when the VA was hitting at staff persons. Staff persons told the VA, “You need to be nice,” and then the VA left staff persons alone. P3 was trained to talk to the VA to redirect the VA when s/he tried to hit staff persons. P3 had not witnessed SP1-SP3 hit the VA.
· P3 had only seen scratches on the VA’s neck. When P3 went to the facility to work, the VA was usually ready to go to school, and then P3 was done with his/her shift before the VA received a bath so P3 did not usually see under the VA’s clothing to note any injuries or marks.
P2 provided the following information:
· P2 was on a telephone call with another client’s guardian when the VA came into the living room and tried to grab a staff person’s drink. The VA ran to his/her bedroom and SP1 went after the VA. After about two minutes the VA came back out with a blanket over his/her head like a veil and P3 asked “What happened to [the VA]?” The VA was bleeding, so staff persons administered first aid. P2 asked SP1 what happened and SP1 said the VA was trying to get into his/her bedroom, was running, and hit his/her head on the doorframe.
· The VA was a “nice little [woman/man]” and the VA had “aggressive behavior.” The VA liked to run around, kick the walls, and punch furniture. When the VA acted this way, P2 said staff persons told the VA to stop. The VA had hit staff persons in the past. P2 had “never” seen staff persons hit the VA.
· The VA hit his/her head on the wall and scratched him/herself. One-time P2 saw the VA hit his/her leg on the VA’s bed because the VA was angry. P2 said s/he did not see bruises on the VA’s calf until one to two days after that incident. P2 said that when the VA hit him/herself on things staff persons would not see the bruises until sometime after when the bruises formed.
P1 provided the following information:
· P1 received a telephone call from SP1 on March 18, 2023, and SP1 told P1 that the VA bumped his/her head on the door and had a deep cut. SP1 called the G and the G took the VA to the hospital. Later when the G found the bruises, it was two different stories from two different staff persons. SP1 told the G that the VA was talking a shower and running from the bathroom and hit his/her head on the doorframe. When the G talked to P2, s/he said the VA was not taking a shower, the VA went to his/her bedroom, and SP1 followed the VA to his/her bedroom. SP1 came back and when the VA came back, s/he had blood on his/her eyebrow.
· The VA went to school Monday through Friday. The VA left around 8 a.m. and arrived back to the facility around 1:30 p.m. The VA liked to go get coffee, s/he was “very energetic.” The VA went up to staff persons in their faces asking for the G. Staff persons told the VA that the G was coming later, so the VA walked away, and then about a minute later the VA was back asking staff persons where the G was.
· The VA hit staff persons, hit his/her head on the wall, and ran “very fast.” There were pads that staff persons used to block the VA when s/he was “aggressive” or hitting people. The VA tried to grab people in the groin area. Staff persons used the pads “all the time,” told the VA to keep his/her hands to him/herself, or went for a walk with the VA to redirect him/her.
· The G sent a video to P1 of the bruises on the VA’s arms. P1 said they looked like finger marks on the VA’s inner arm. There were three on each arm and they looked bright blue with purplish edges starting to turn brown. P1 said the bruises looked a few days old. No one had mentioned anything about bruises at the facility and it was not known when the bruises happened.
SP2 provided the following information:
· The VA had hit SP2 a few times and when that happened SP2 redirected the VA by telling him/her to stop, not to do that anymore, or go to his/her bedroom. SP2 saw staff persons direct the VA to his/her bedroom with their hands on the VA’s back before, but SP2 had not witnessed a staff person hit the VA and SP2 denied hitting the VA.
· One occasion when SP1 was getting the VA ready for bed, SP2 thought s/he heard SP1 hit the VA with keys. SP2 did not see this and did not know if SP1 was hitting the VA or the bed with keys, but SP2 said the VA was “screaming.” When SP1 came out of the VA’s bedroom, SP2 checked on the VA and did not see any marks.
· The VA hit him/herself a lot and had bruises. SP2 said the bruises were small and round on the VA’s arms and legs. There were usually one or two bruises on the VA’s arm around his/her elbow or a little further up on the VA’s arm.
SP1 provided the following information:
· The day of the incident, SP1 was working with P2 and P3 and they were in the living room. The VA was “angry” and hitting staff persons. SP1 had the keys and opened the VA’s bedroom door for the VA to sit inside. SP1 went out of the bedroom, the VA went in, and then soon after, the VA went out of his/her room and s/he was bleeding. P2 said to take a picture and to call the G. SP1 called the G and they “FaceTimed.” The G picked up the VA and they went to the hospital. SP1 said s/he did not know how the VA got hurt, but when SP1 went back to the VA’s bedroom the border of the door had blood on it. SP1 denied doing anything to the VA to make him/her bleed.
· When the VA hit staff persons, they told him/her, “Ow,” and “Be careful.” SP1 “never” saw staff persons hit the VA. SP1 had witnessed SP2 “hold” the VA’s arms and “push” the VA. SP1 was not able to describe how SP2’s hands were on the VA’s arms and could not provide further details. SP1 denied pushing or hitting the VA.
· The facility had two key rings for staff persons to access the doors inside the facility. There were six or seven keys on each ring. SP1 denied ever hitting the VA with keys or throwing them at the VA.
The facility’s Internal Review provided the following information:
· C2 stated s/he had not witnessed or heard staff persons hit the VA.
· SP1 said s/he had not been in a situation at the facility when the VA was hit by a staff person. SP1 stated that s/he had not had to put his/her hands on the VA for re-direction or for any other reason.
· SP2 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons hitting the VA.
· SP3 stated that s/he had “never” had a situation where s/he had to put his/her hands on the VA. SP3 stated s/he carried a blocking pad with him/her constantly when the VA was awake at night because the VA tried to touch inappropriate areas and got “aggressive.” SP3 said s/he verbally redirected the VA when s/he ran around and the VA “calm[ed] well in [his/her] room.” SP3 stated that the VA hit his/her head, back, or the wall with his/her fists when s/he was “agitated.” SP3 had not heard of or witnessed other staff persons hit the VA. SP3 denied hitting the VA.
· P5 stated that SP1 was “helpful” in aiding P5 with the VA during shifts. P5 had not witnessed anything problematic about how SP1 supported the clients at the facility. P5 said that SP3 showed P5 how to use verbal re-direction and the blocking pads to re-direct the VA. P5 stated that SP3 was a “great support staff [person]” for the VA.
· P6 stated s/he would not stand for anyone harming the VA and that was part of his/her job to protect the VA. P6 had worked with SP1 and had not heard or witnessed anything from SP1 towards the VA that would be considered abuse or maltreatment. P6 did not work with SP3 but saw him/her in passing. P6 said s/he did not see any “strange behavior” from the VA after relieving SP3 and P6 had not seen any marks or bruising on the VA after SP3 worked with the VA. P6 stated that the VA hit him/herself or hit his/her head into the wall and that staff persons tried their best to help the VA and treated him/her “very well.” P6 stated that staff persons “never” mistreated the VA or displayed any anger towards the VA.
· P2 stated that SP1 did not “do anything wrong” in the incident where the VA hit his/her head on the doorframe causing a cut to the VA. P2 stated that s/he worked with SP3 once or twice and “[SP3] takes very good care of [the VA].” P2 stated s/he had not heard of or witnessed SP3 hit any client.
· P7 stated that there was nothing out of the ordinary about how SP1 supported the clients. P7 only worked with SP3 for small periods of time in the morning and there was not anything that indicated that SP3 was being abusive towards the clients in any way. P7 had not observed any bruising on the VA. P7 had not observed any verbal or physical aggression from staff persons towards the VA and that staff persons verbally redirected the VA with his/her behaviors. P7 stated that the VA often ran and jumped around the house and sometimes threw him/herself into the wall or onto the couch which could “potentially cause bruising.”
· P8 stated that s/he had never heard anything negative about SP1 or about how SP1 and SP3 treated the clients.
· P9 stated that s/he had not observed any verbal or physical aggression such as yelling or grabbing from staff persons towards the VA. P9 stated that s/he had not observed any bruises on the VA but stated that the VA tended to run around which resulted in the VA running into walls, door, or other objects.
· P1, P3, P5, P6, SP1, and SP2 each stated that they saw other facility clients hit and push the VA when the VA and other clients were aggressing toward each other. Staff persons redirected and stood in between the VA and other clients.
Law enforcement investigated and no further action was taken. Conclusion for Allegation One:
Regarding the VA hitting his/her head on a doorframe causing a laceration to the VA’s right eyebrow:
On March 18, 2023, the VA sustained a cut above his/her right eyebrow. P2 and P3 stated that the VA tried to grab a drink but P2 stated that the VA ran to his/her bedroom after trying to grab the drink, while P3 stated that SP1 brought the VA to his/her bedroom to take a break. SP1 stated that the VA was hitting staff persons, so SP1 had the VA go to his/her bedroom to sit down. SP1, P2, and P3 all stated that after that the VA came out of his/her bedroom, s/he had a cut above his/her eye. Staff persons administered first aid and SP1 called the G to tell him/her what happened. The G “FaceTimed” with SP1 and picked the VA up to go to the doctor. The VA did not require stitches for his/her cut. The G took a photo of the VA’s cut which showed a laceration to the VA’s right eyebrow approximately ½ inch in length. SP1, P2, and P3 were not sure how the VA sustained the eye injury, but P2 did not think SP1 caused injury to the VA, and SP1 denied doing anything to the VA that caused the injury. P1-P3 all stated that the VA hit his/her head on the wall in the past although it never caused bleeding before. No one witnessed the injury happen.
While there were slight variations in what SP1, P2, and P3 remembered what happened the day the VA sustained his/her eye injury, it was consistent that the VA was going back and forth to his/her bedroom and came out with a cut above his/her right eyebrow. Given that the staff persons administered first aid and contacted the G to advise him/her what was going on, there was not a preponderance of the evidence whether the injury to the VA was caused by anything other than an accident.
Regarding staff persons hitting the VA:
P4 stated that SP1 told him/her that s/he hit the VA and “lied” to the G about how the VA got hurt. P4 said that SP3 told him/her to just hit the VA back when the VA hit P4. P4 said that SP2 also hit the VA. P4 provided conflicting information regarding working with SP1 (P4 said s/he worked with SP1 daily but P4 was not listed as a staff person at the facility) and incorrect information regarding SP3’s gender identity. In addition, P4 did not provide additional information and did not respond to attempts to obtain further information.
SP2 said one occasion when SP1 was getting the VA ready for bed, SP2 thought s/he heard SP1 hit the VA with keys. SP2 did not see this and did not know if SP1 was hitting the VA or the bed with the keys s/he had, but SP2 said the VA was “screaming.” When SP1 came out of the VA’s bedroom, SP2 checked on the VA and did not see any marks. SP1, SP2, and SP3 each denied hitting the VA and SP1 denied hitting the VA with keys or throwing keys at the VA.
C2, P1, P2, P3, and P5-P8 did not hear of or have concerns with how SP1, SP2, and SP3 treated the clients.
Although P4 stated that s/he saw SP1-SP3 hit the VA, SP1 told P4 s/he hit the VA, and SP3 told P4 to hit the VA if the VA hit P4, given that SP1-SP3 each denied hitting the VA, P4 provided incomplete and conflicting information and did not respond to provide further details, that C2, P2, P3, and P5-P8 did not hear of or have concerns with how SP1, SP2, and SP3 treated the clients, that SP2 did not see SP1 hit the VA with keys, and without further information to support or refute these allegations, there was not a preponderance of the evidence whether the SP1-SP3 engaged in actions that were not an accident or not therapeutic conduct which produced or could reasonably be expected to produce physical pain or injury or emotional distress.
Regarding bruises on the VA’s arm:
On March 25, 2023, the VA went home with the G and the G removed the VA’s long-sleeved shirt and noticed bruising on both of the VA’s upper arms. The G sent the video to P1 who said the bruises looked like finger marks on the VA’s inner arm. There were three on each arm and they looked bright blue with purplish edges starting to turn brown. P1 said the bruises looked a few days old. No one had mentioned anything about bruises at the facility and it was not known when the bruises happened. After this incident the facility began using a body chart to document any new marks on the VA. When P4 asked SP2 about it SP2 told P4 it was because the G was “suspicious” how the VA got hurt. P4 saw two bruises on the VA’s lower right arm that were reddish, and purple in color. SP1 stated s/he witnessed SP2 hold the VA’s arms and push the VA. SP1 was not able to describe how SP2’s hands were on the VA’s arms and did not provide further details.
SP1 and SP3 stated that they had not had to put their hands on the VA to redirect the VA. SP2 said the VA hit him/herself a lot and had bruises. SP2 said the bruises were small and round on his/her arms and legs. There were usually one or two bruises on the VA’s arm around his/her elbow or a little further up on the VA’s arm.
While there was video footage that showed bruising to the VA’s upper arms that were consistent with fingerprints, P4 and SP2 noticed bruises on the VA’s upper arms, and that SP1 saw SP2 put his/her hands on the VA’s arms, given that SP1 was not able to describe how SP2 put his/her hands on the VA’s arms or provide further details, SP1 and SP3 stated that they had not had to put their hands on the VA to redirect the VA before, that the VA engaged in self-injurious behaviors, that other clients hit or pushed the VA at times, and that C2, P2, P3, and P5-P8 did not hear of or have concerns with how SP1 and SP3 treated the clients, there was not a preponderance of the evidence whether the VA’s bruising was caused by staff persons’ actions.
It was not determined whether physical abuse occurred (conduct which is not an accident or therapeutic conduct which produces or could reasonably be expected to produce physical pain or injury or emotional distress including, but not limited to: hitting, slapping, kicking, pinching, biting, or corporal punishment of a vulnerable adult).
Allegation Two: It was reported that SP1 took money from the VA.
The VA’s CSSP stated that the G was the VA’s financial representative. The VA’s IAPP stated that “due to [the VA’s] cognitive ability, staff [persons] and guardians will assist [him/her] with all financial matters.” The facility’s Financial Authorization for the VA stated that the VA needed assistance from the facility with cash resources and the facility procedures for that were, “Staff [persons] will assist [VA] in making purchases.”
P4 stated that the VA and other facility clients all had money and SP1 went out into the community with whichever client s/he was working with that day and had them purchase SP1 something or SP1 just used the clients’ money. Other than food, SP1 was not specific to what s/he had purchased but one occasionSP1 told P4 that it was “something expensive.” P4 told this investigator that s/he worked with SP1 “almost every day,” however, facility documentation did not show P4 listed on the staff schedule to work with SP1. This investigator reached out to P4 by several means for clarification, and s/he did not respond to those attempts to obtain clarifying and additional information.
The G was not aware of any mishandling of the VA’s money. The G provided cash to the facility so that staff persons were able to take the VA out to places in the community.
SP2, P1, P2, P3, P6, P7, and P8 provided information that they were trained on handling the clients’ petty cash and provided the following information for the facility internal review and to this investigator:
· SP2 stated s/he had not heard of or witnessed staff persons taking money and would let a supervisor know. SP2 stated s/he took the VA’s money from the VA’s wallet, purchased the item for the VA, and saved a receipt. SP2 stated that the VA liked to purchase a cold ice coffee.
· P1 said the G brought $20-$40 per week spending money for the VA and that there were no issues that led P1 to believe staff persons had taken clients’ money. P1 stated that the facility was getting a new system of “showing” how much money was given, how much money was spent, and how much money remained. P1 audited the VA’s petty cash, and the amounts matched the receipts left in the pouch by staff persons.
· P2 stated that the clients all had a bag with money in it that had his/her name on it. P2 said staff persons purchased items and put a receipt in the bag. P2 had not heard of staff persons taking clients’ money.
· P3 was able to provide the exact dollar amount of the iced coffee the VA purchased daily. P3 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons taking clients’ money.
· P6 stated that s/he took five or six dollars out of the VA’s pouch to take the VA to purchase a coffee, and after put change and the receipt back in the pouch. P6 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons taking clients’ money and would tell a supervisor if s/he had.
· P7 took money out, used it for the purchases for the client, got a receipt and change and returned those to the pouch. P7 had not heard of staff persons taking clients’ money for themselves.
· P8 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons take clients’ money.
P5 and SP3 did not handle clients’ money and had not heard of missing clients’ money.
SP1 stated that s/he took money out of the clients’ pouch, went on the outings with the clients, and returned receipts and change to the client’s pouch. SP1 stated that the VA liked to purchase small, iced coffees. SP1 stated that staff persons wrote down the date and how much was left of the client’s money. SP1 denied taking the VA’s or any clients’ money for him/herself.
Facility documentation showed that there was a “ledger” that showed how much money was spent on the VA’s trips to get coffee, when the G brought in more money, and a remaining balance. However, this was not filled out daily and no entries had been made since February 23, 2023.
Conclusion for Allegation Two:
P4 stated that SP1 told him/her that SP1 used clients’ money to purchase items or had the clients purchase items for SP1 when SP1 took the clients on outings. SP1 told P4 that one time s/he purchased “something expensive.”
SP2, P1, P2, P3, P6, P7, and P8 provided information that they were trained on handling the clients’ petty cash. SP2, SP3, P2, P3, and P5-P8 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons taking or using clients’ money. P1 audited the VA’s petty cash, and the amounts matched the receipts. P1 stated that there had been no issues with the clients’ petty cash. SP1 provided information that s/he was familiar with the process of using the client’s petty cash and denied using the VA’s or any client’s money for him/herself. The G was not aware of any mishandling of the VA’s money.
Although P4 stated that SP1 told him/her that SP1 used clients’ money P4 told this investigator that s/he worked with SP1 “almost every day,” however, facility documentation did not show P4 listed on the staff schedule to work with SP1. This investigator reached out to P4 by several means for clarification, and s/he did not respond to those attempts to obtain clarifying and additional information. The VA’s “ledger” was not filled out after each time the VA made a purchase, however given that other staff persons had not heard of or witnessed clients’ money missing, and that P1 audited the VA’s petty cash and the balances matched the receipts in the VA’s pouch, there was not a preponderance of the evidence whether willfully used clients’ money in the absence of legal authority.
It was not determined whether financial exploitation occurred (in the absence of legal authority, a person willfully uses, withholds, or disposes of funds or property of a vulnerable adult).
Allegation Three: It was reported that staff persons allowed C1 and C2 to hit the VA.
P4 stated that one day the G dropped off the VA at the facility and P4 heard SP2 tell C1 not to hit the VA because the G was still sitting in the driveway and could see inside the facility. P4 said C1 and C2 called the VA names such as “the B word,” told the VA to go to his/her bedroom, and hit the VA. This investigator reached out to P4 by several means for clarification, and s/he did not respond to those attempts to obtain clarifying and additional information.
The following information was provided to this investigator through interviews or during the Internal Review:
· P1 stated that in the past C1 and C2 had pushed and grabbed the VA’s hair when the VA got too close to C1 and C2. The VA also liked to grab C1’s and C2’s drinks. P1 said staff persons redirected C1 and C2 and went in between the VA and C1 and C2 and told them it was not okay to hit the VA and that the G could “press charges.”
· P3 stated that C1 and C2 hit the VA and staff persons told them not to do it. Staff persons were assigned a client each day and sometimes C2 wanted more attention and C2 complained to P2 that P2 spent too much time with the VA. P2 explained that s/he was assigned to the VA that day and other staff persons worked with C2. P3 saw C1 and C2 hit the VA and P3 talked with C1’s and C2’s behavior teams. P3 had not heard C1 or C2 call the VA names and had not heard or witnessed staff persons say it was okay for C1 and C2 to hit the VA.
· C2 stated that s/he was “never” told by staff persons that it was okay for C1 and C2 to hit the VA. C2 was not told it was okay to say mean things or call the VA names.
· SP1 stated that C1 and C2 hit and kicked the VA when the VA “bothered” C1 and C2. When that happened staff persons tried to stop C1 and C2. SP1 did not hear any staff person tell C1 and C2 to hit the VA. SP1 heard C1 and C2 call the VA names and staff persons verbally redirected C1 and C2 when that happened.
· SP3 provided consistent information as SP1 and stated that C2 was easily redirected.
· P2 had not seen C1 or C2 hit the VA on P2’s shift. P2 had not heard C1 and C2 call the VA bad names and had not heard staff persons say it was okay for C1 and C2 to hit the VA.
· P5 had not heard or witnessed staff persons say it was okay for C1 and C2 to hit the VA or call the VA names. P5 witnessed C2 push the VA and P4 got in between right away and called 9-1-1.
· P6 said staff persons had told C1 and C2 not to hit the VA when they became angry. P6 said this usually happened when the VA grabbed C1's and C2’s drinks. P6 had not heard of or witnessed any staff person tell C1 and C2 it was okay to hit the VA or call the VA mean names. Staff persons told C1 and C2, “Be nice, give [the VA] space, or calm down.”
· P7 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons say it was okay for C1 and C2 to call the VA bad names or hit the VA. P7 stated that when C1 and C2 called the VA names, they were verbally redirected by staff persons.
· P8 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons say it was okay for C1 and C2 to hit the VA or call the VA names.
· SP2 saw C2 hit the VA when C2 did not like what the VA did. SP2 told C2 that that was “not right, cannot hit, and to stop it.” SP2 got in between the VA and C2 in the past and C2 had called the VA mean names. SP2 said that when s/he redirected C1 and C2, they stopped what they were doing. SP2 denied telling C1 and C2 to hit the VA.
On March 30, 2023, an Incident Report stated the VA grabbed another client’s drink and that client pushed the VA causing the VA to nearly fall. SP3 got to the VA before s/he fell, and the VA sustained no injury.
Conclusion for Allegation Three:
P4 stated that one day when the G dropped off the VA at the facility, P4 heard SP2 tell C1 not to hit the VA because the G was still sitting in the driveway and could see inside the facility. P4 said C1 and C2 called the VA names such as “the B word,” told the VA to go to his/her bedroom, and hit the VA. This investigator reached out to P4 by several means for clarification, and s/he did not respond to those attempts to obtain clarifying and additional information.
P1, P3, P5, P6, and SP1-SP3 had witnessed C1 and/or C2 hit, push or grab the VA, usually when the VA had grabbed C1’s or C2’s drink. SP1-SP3 and P7 had heard C1 and/or C2 call the VA names. When C1 and C2 hit, pushed, grabbed, or called the VA names, P1, P3, P5, P6, P7, and SP1-SP3 said staff persons intervened and redirected C1 and C2.
C2, SP1, SP3, P2, P3, and P5-P8 had not heard of or witnessed staff persons tell C1 and C2 it was okay to hit the VA or call the VA names. C2 stated that s/he was “never” told by staff persons it was okay for C1 and C2 to hit the VA. SP2 denied telling C1 and C2 to hit the VA.
Although P4 stated that s/he heard SP2 tell C2 not to hit the VA because the G was still in the driveway, given that several other staff persons had not heard of or witnessed SP2 or any staff person tell C1 and C2 that it was okay to hit the VA, that C2 stated s/he was “never” told by a staff person it was okay to hit the VA, and that when C1 and C2 hit, pushed or grabbed the VA, staff persons intervened and redirected C1 and C2, there was a preponderance of the evidence that SP2 and other staff persons did not fail to provide services reasonable to maintain the VA’s physical and mental health and safety.
It was determined that neglect did not occur (the failure or omission by a caregiver to supply a vulnerable adult with care or services, including but not limited to food, clothing, shelter, health care, or supervision which is reasonable and necessary to obtain or maintain the vulnerable adult's physical or mental health or safety, considering the physical and mental capacity or dysfunction of the vulnerable adult and which is not the result of an accident or therapeutic conduct).
Action Taken by Facility:
The facility completed and Internal Review and found their policies and procedures adequate and followed by SP1-SP3. P1 was retrained on reporting to the VA’s team within 24 hours of an incident. On March 27, 2023, the facility implemented a body/bruise chart for the VA to be completed daily by facility staff persons. SP1 no longer worked at the facility location where the VA resided.
Action Taken by Department of Human Services, Office of Inspector General:
No further action taken.
PO Box 64242 • Saint Paul, Minnesota • 55164-0242 • An Equal Opportunity and Veteran Friendly Employer https://mn.gov/dhs/general-public/licensing/
|