|
September 8, 2023 CERTIFIED MAIL Laurie Franklin 4994 Shady Lane North Branch, MN 55056 License Number 1048088 FCC ORDER OF CONDITIONAL LICENSE ORDER TO PAY A FINE Dear Ms. Franklin: Based on the recommendation of Chisago County Health and Human Services (Chisago County), the Department of Human Services (DHS) is placing your license to provide family child care at 4994 Shady Lane, North Branch, MN on conditional status for one year beginning September 8, 2023. This means you must meet certain conditions to maintain your license, detailed below. This order is based on your level of noncompliance with family child care licensing requirements. Our next steps and your options are also provided below. In addition, DHS is ordering you to pay a fine of $200. Details of our findings are provided below. REASON FOR THE CONDITIONAL LICENSE 1. Commissioner’s evaluation of program In determining whether a licensing action is warranted, DHS evaluated the facts, conditions, and circumstances concerning your program’s operation. This includes consideration of the well-being of children served in your program, available evaluations from consumers of your program, and information about the qualifications of caregivers working in your program. Specifically, you have repeatedly failed to operate within the license capacity and distribution limits of your license. DHS has determined that it is appropriate to place your license on conditional status based on the violations identified below and the program evaluation. Legal Authority: Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.04, subdivision 6. 2. Failure to comply with licensing laws and rules As a result of previous licensing visits, Chisago County determined that your program failed to comply with the laws and rules for licensed family child care. DHS has considered the nature, chronicity, and severity of these violations, which are provided below. Legal Authority: Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 1. Nature, history and severity of violations Violations determined On May 23, 2023, Chisago County made a relicensing visit to your family child care program. As a result of the visit, Chisago County determined that you failed to operate within the capacity and distribution limits of your license when you were caring for 13 children under school age and a total of 16 children. You were allowed to care for no more than 10 children under school age and a total of no more than 14 children. You were issued a correction order for this licensing violation. On June 1, 2023, Chisago County made a follow up visit to your family child care program. As a result of the visit, it was determined that you failed to operate within the capacity and distribution limits of your license when you were caring for 13 children under school age and a total of 16 children. You were allowed to care for no more than 10 children under school age and a total of no more than 14 children. You were issued a correction order for this licensing violation. Subsequently, Chisago County received a report regarding your family child care program. The report alleged that you may be operating over the capacity limits of your license. On June 16, 2023, Chisago County made an unannounced visit to your family child care program. As a result of the visit, it was determined that you provided false or misleading when you had a child listed as a five year old child on a food program enrollment form. Chisago County determined that the child was three years old. You were issued a correction order for operating over the distribution limits of your license when you were caring for 11 children under school age. You were allowed to care for no more than ten children under school age. Rule Violated: Minnesota Rules, part 9502.0367, C 3. Severity of violations Due to the serious and chronic nature of these violations, and the conditions in the program, which impact the health and safety of children served in your care, your license to provide family child care is placed on a conditional status. Conditional License Terms In addition to the licensing rules and statutes for family child care, you are required to comply with the following terms: 1. You will follow and comply with all applicable Minnesota Rules and Laws. 2. No variances to age distribution or capacity will be granted during the conditional period. 3. You must notify Chisago County prior to the enrollment of any new children in your family child care, including drop-in children. Chisago County must approve all new enrollments prior to you providing care. 4. You must submit daily attendance records to Chisago County on a monthly basis. The records must be submitted by the 5th of each month for the previous month beginning October 5, 2023. The records must show the name and the date of birth of each child, the days and hours they were in your care, and must include parent sign in and sign out signatures. 5. You must submit daily staff work time records to Chisago County on a monthly basis. The records must be submitted by the 5th of the month for the previous month beginning October 5, 2023. The records must show the staff name, date and time worked, and staff signature. 6. You must obtain a minimum of six hours of additional training within 60 days of this order. The training is in addition to the annual training requirements as listed in Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.50. The training must be in the area of supervision and child safety. You must obtain approval from Chisago County that the training is appropriate, and you must submit documentation of your attendance to Chisago County.
7. You must either provide a copy of the Order to Pay a Fine and Order of Conditional License to parents of children in care or document that all parents have been given an opportunity to review the Order. You must obtain parent signatures of each currently enrolled child, indicating they have either received a copy of the Order or had an opportunity to review the Order. You must provide this documentation to Chisago County by September 29, 2023. For new families, you must submit documentation of compliance with this term to Chisago County within 5 days of any child’s admission to your child care program. Ongoing Monitoring Your Chisago County licensor will monitor your compliance with these terms and with all of the family child care rules and laws. This will include unannounced visits. If you fail to demonstrate substantial compliance with family child care requirements or with the terms of your conditional license that are provided above, DHS may take an additional licensing sanction, including a revocation of your license. REASON FOR FINE Failure to Comply with Correction Order Violations determined On May 23, 2023, Chisago County made a relicensing visit to your family child care program. As a result of the visit, Chisago County determined that you failed to operate within the capacity and distribution limits of your license when you were caring for 13 children under school age and a total of 16 children. You were allowed to care for no more than 10 children under school age and a total of no more than 14 children. You were issued a correction order for this licensing violation. On June 1, 2023, Chisago County made a follow up visit to your family child care program. As a result of the visit, it was determined that you failed to operate within the capacity and distribution limits of your license when you were caring for 13 children under school age and a total of 16 children. You were allowed to care for no more than 10 children under school age and a total of no more than 14 children. You were issued a correction order for this licensing violation. Subsequently, Chisago County received a report regarding your family child care program. The report alleged that you may be operating over the capacity limits of your license. On June 16, 2023, Chisago County made an unannounced visit to your family child care program. As a result of the visit, you provided false or misleading when you had a child listed as a five-year-old child on a food program enrollment form. Chisago County determined that the child was three years old. You were issued a correction order for operating over the distribution limits of your license when you were caring for 11 children under school age. You were allowed to care for no more than ten children under school age. You have repeatedly failed to operate within the license capacity and distribution limits of your license. Statute Violated: Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 3. Fine: $200 Total Fine Amount $200 YOUR APPEAL/RECONSIDERATION RIGHTS If You Wish to Appeal the Fine and the Conditional License, or Just the Fine You have the right to appeal both the fine and the conditional license, or only the fine. Your request must be in writing and clearly state that you are requesting a contested case hearing for this matter. Your request must be made before the deadlines provided below. If you do not meet this deadline, you lose your right to an administrative appeal. The timeline to appeal began when you received this order. If you are mailing your request, it must be sent by certified mail and postmarked within 10 calendar days from when you receive this order. Please send it to: Commissioner, Department of Human Services Office of Inspector General Legal Counsel’s Office Attention: Licensing Legal Unit PO Box 64953 St. Paul, MN 55164-0953 If your request is being personally delivered, it must be received by DHS within 10 calendar days from when you receive this order. Please bring it to: Commissioner, Department of Human Services Office of Inspector General Legal Counsel’s Office Attention: Licensing Legal Unit 444 Lafayette Road North St. Paul, MN 55155 Upon DHS’ receipt of your timely appeal, your case would be scheduled for a contested case hearing in front of an Administrative Law Judge. Following this hearing, the Commissioner of DHS will issue a final order. If You Wish to Only Appeal the Conditional License If you are not appealing the fine, you do not have a right to a contested case hearing. However, you have the right to request reconsideration of the conditional license and the cited violations. Your request must: · Be in writing · Clearly state that you are requesting reconsideration of the conditional license · List each citation you are challenging and identify what is inaccurate or incomplete about the information in the order · Supply information that is accurate or more complete · State why you believe your license should not be on a conditional status · Be made before the deadlines provided below If you are mailing your request, it must be sent by certified mail and postmarked within 10 calendar days from when you received this order. If you do not meet this deadline, you lose your right to request reconsideration. The timeline to appeal began when you received this order. Please send it to: Commissioner, Department of Human Services Office of Inspector General Licensing Division Attention: Legal Unit PO Box 64242 St. Paul, MN 55164-0242 If your request is being personally delivered, it must be received by DHS within 10 calendar days from when you received this order. Please bring it to: Commissioner, Department of Human Services Office of Inspector General Licensing Division Attention: Legal Unit 444 Lafayette Road North St. Paul, MN 55155 Billing and Payment of the Fine DHS will send you an invoice for the $200 fine. Payment must be made as directed on the invoice. If you request a contested case hearing, as described above, do not pay the fine at this time. Following the contested case hearing, the Commissioner of DHS will issue a final order on this matter. Please note, you may not avoid payment of this fine by closing, selling, or otherwise transferring the license to a third party. If this occurs, you are personally responsible for payment. If you do not pay the fine on or before the date specified on the invoice and you did not request a contested case hearing, as described above, the Commissioner may issue a second fine, may not issue or reissue a license, or may suspend the license until the license holder pays the fine. Conditional license stayed pending reconsideration If you request reconsideration within the timeframes described above, the terms of the conditional license will not take effect until a decision is issued by DHS. If the conditional license is affirmed on reconsideration, the terms would take effect on the date of the reconsideration decision, and run for one year from that date. You continue to be required to comply with all family child care laws and rules. Legal representation at the contested case hearing You do not need a lawyer to appeal. However, a lawyer can help you with your appeal. The state or county will not get you a lawyer and will not pay for a lawyer. If you cannot afford a lawyer, you may be able to get free legal advice or help with your appeal. To find out if free help is available, contact: Volunteer Lawyers Network at 612-752-6677; Central Minnesota Legal Services at 612-332-8151; Southern Minnesota Legal Services at 651-222-4731; or go to www.lawhelpmn.org to find a local legal services program that may be able to help you. You can also find information on contested cases from the Office of Administrative Hearings website at https://mn.gov/oah/self-help. Click on Administrative Law Overview, then click on Administrative Law Contested Case Hearing Guide for a list of frequently asked questions. Prohibition against providing legally unlicensed child care As a result of this order, you are prohibited from providing legally unlicensed child care. A child care provider who has received a conditional license or fine that has not been reversed on reconsideration or appeal may not provide legally unlicensed child care to non-relatives. Operating a prohibited unlicensed family child care program is a misdemeanor offense. Posting of this licensing action You are required to place this Order to Pay a Fine and Order of Conditional License in a place that is clearly noticeable to the people receiving services and all visitors to the facility for two years, even if you appeal. Legal authority for this licensing action · This action is taken under Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.07, subdivision 1, paragraph (a), which describes under which conditions DHS may impose a fine against a license. · Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.07, subdivision 3, paragraph (c)(5) states that license holders may not avoid payment of a fine by closing, selling, or transferring a license. · Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.04, subdivision 7, paragraph (d)(4), states that DHS shall not issue or reissue a license if the applicant, license holder, or controlling individual has an outstanding debt related to a license fee, licensing fine, or settlement agreement for which payment is delinquent. · Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.07, subdivision 3, paragraph (c)(2), states that that the license holder shall pay the fine assessed on or before the payment date specified, and if the license holder does not do so the commissioner may issue a second fine or suspend the license until the license holder complies. · The timeline to request reconsideration of the order of conditional license is provided in Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 4. · License holders have a right to appeal licensing actions and request a contested case hearing, under Minnesota Statutes, chapter 14 and Minnesota Rules, parts 1400.8505 to 1400.8612. · If a license holder files a timely reconsideration request, the terms of the conditional license are stayed pending a decision by DHS under Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 4. · Under Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 4, if DHS issues a dual order to pay a fine and a conditional license and the license holder appeals both the fine and the conditional license, DHS will not do a separate reconsideration of the conditional license. If the license holder does not appeal the fine but requests reconsideration of the conditional license, then the license holder does not have a right to a hearing and DHS will conduct a reconsideration of the conditional license. · The requirement to post this order in a clearly visible location is required under Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 8 and Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.07, subdivision 5. · Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 245A.03, subdivision 2b, subdivision 1 states that a child care provider who has received a conditional license and fine under Minnesota Statutes, Section 245A.06 that has not been reversed on reconsideration or appeal may not provide unlicensed child care to non-relatives. · Operating a prohibited unlicensed family child care program is a misdemeanor offense under Minnesota Statutes, Section 245A.03, subdivision 3. Questions If you have any further questions regarding this matter, you may contact Beth Donahue, Supervisor at 651-431-6565. Sincerely,
Barbara Wagner, Unit Manager Licensing Division Office of Inspector General cc: Lanay Miller, Chisago County Health and Human Services
|
