|

October 27, 2023
Nom Thao, Authorized Agent Lashia Elderly Care Center 2355 Ariel Street North Maplewood, Minnesota 55109
License Number: 1095908 (Rule 223) Dear Nom Thao: This matter arises from an Order of Conditional License, dated March 15, 2023. (See attached “Exhibit A”). On April 3, 2023, the Minnesota Department of Human Services (DHS), Licensing Division, received the license holder’s request for reconsideration of the Order of Conditional License. The license holder requested reconsideration of Citations 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, and 8. The license holder did not request reconsideration of Citation 4. A. RECONSIDERATION OF THE CITATIONS IDENTIFIED IN THE ORDER OF CONDITIONAL LICENSE PARTICIPANT RECORD VIOLATIONS
1. Violation: For two participants whose records were reviewed (P1 and P2), the license holder did not meet the requirements for an individual abuse prevention plan (IAPP).
The license holder failed to review P1 and P2’s IAPPs quarterly as part of the review of the program plan or service plan.
· P1’s IAPP was most recently reviewed on February 4, 2022.
· P2’s IAPP was most recently reviewed on March 3, 2021.
Statute Violated: Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 2, paragraph (b).
Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you previously found in violation of this same subdivision.
Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 2(b). The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the license holder did not meet the requirements for P1 and P2’s IAPPs because it failed to review them quarterly, as required by Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65. subdivision 2(b)(2), and Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9700, subpart 3. This citation is modified to add the citation to Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9700, subpart 3. This violation was correct and it is affirmed. 2. Violation: For three of three participants whose records were reviewed (P1, P2 and P3), the license holder did not include information in the participant’s written record as required.
a. The license holder failed to include the following information in P1’s record:
· an application form that included P1’s source of referral; and
· a medical report, dated within the three months prior to or 30 days after P1’s admission to the center signed by a physician or signed by a physician assistant or registered nurse and cosigned by a physician, that included:
o a medical history of P1;
o indication of dietary restrictions and medication regimen, including the need for medication assistance, that apply to P1;
o a release signed by the physician indicating whether P1 may engage in a structured exercise program; and
o documentation that P1 was free of communicable disease or infestations, as specified in parts 4605.7000 to 4605.7090, that would endanger the health of other participants.
b. The license holder failed to include the following information in P2’s record:
· an application form signed by P2 or P2’s caregiver that included:
o P2’s living arrangement and telephone number;
o the name and telephone number of the person to call in case of an emergency involving P2 and the name and number of another person to call if that person cannot be reached; and
o the name and telephone number of P2’s physician or medical provider;
· a medical report, dated within the three months prior to or 30 days after P1’s admission to the center signed by a physician or signed by a physician assistant or registered nurse and cosigned by a physician, that included:
o a report on a physical examination, update annually;
o a medical history of P1;
o indication of dietary restrictions and medication regimen, including the need for medication assistance, that apply to P1;
o a release signed by the physician indicating whether P1 may engage in a structured exercise program; and
o documentation that P1 was free of communicable disease or infestations, as specified in parts 4605.7000 to 4605.7090, that would endanger the health of other participants.
c. The license holder failed to include the following information in P3’s record:
· an application form signed by P3 or P3’s caregiver that included the name and telephone number of a secondary person to call in case of an emergency involving P3; and · a medical report that included documentation that P3 was free of communicable disease or infestations, as specified in parts 4605.7000 to 4605.7090, that would endanger the health of other participants.
Rule Violated: Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9660, subparts 1 and 3.
Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you were previously found in violation of the same subparts.
Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9660, subparts 1 and 3. The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the license holder did not include all of the required information in P1 and P3’s written record, as explained above in citation 2(a) and (c). Regarding citation 2(b), the first bullet point is modified to remove “the name and telephone number of P2’s physician or medical provider,” and “the name and telephone number of the person to call in case of an emergency involving P2,” because that information was included on the application form signed by P2 or P2’s caregiver. However, citation 2(b) is affirmed, as modified, because the rest of the violation is supported by the record. Therefore, the license holder did not meet the requirements of Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9660, subpart 1. This violation was correct and it is affirmed, with the modification to citation 2(b), as described in this response. 3. Violation: For one participant whose record was reviewed (P3), the license holder did not complete initial service planning as required.
The license holder failed to develop a preliminary service plan for P3 based on the assessment in item A and coordinated with other plans of service for P3 within 30 days of P3’s admission that included the role of P3’s caregiver or caregivers in carrying out the service plan.
Rule Violated: Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9700, subpart 2.
Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you were previously found in violation of this same subpart.
Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9700, subpart 2. The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the preliminary service plan for P3 did not include the role of the participant’s caregiver or caregivers in carrying out the service plan, as required by Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9700, subpart 2, item B(4). Therefore, this citation was correct and it is affirmed. PERSONNEL RECORD VIOLATIONS
5. Violation: For one of two staff persons whose records were reviewed (SP1), the license holder did not maintain a personnel record as required. The license holder failed to maintain documentation of an annual performance evaluation in SP1’s personnel record.
Rule Violated: Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9650, item A. Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you were previously found in violation of this same subpart. Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9650, item A. The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the license holder’s personnel record for SP1 did not include documentation of an annual performance evaluation for SP1. Therefore, the license holder failed to comply with Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9650, item A(5). This citation was correct and it is affirmed. 6. Violation: For one staff whose record was reviewed (SP1), the license holder did not provide annual review to a mandated reporter as required.
The license holder failed to provide SP1 an annual review to the reporting requirements and definitions in sections 626.557 and 626.5572, the requirements of this section, the license holder’s program abuse prevention plan, and all internal policies and procedures related to the prevention and reporting of maltreatment of individuals receiving services.
Statute Violated: Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 3. Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you were previously found in violation of this same subdivision. Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 3. The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the license holder did not ensure that SP1 received an annual review of the reporting requirements and definitions in sections 626.557 and 626.5572, the requirements of the section, the license holder’s program abuse prevention plan, and all internal policies and procedures related to the prevention and reporting of maltreatment of individuals receiving services. Therefore, the license holder violated Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 3. This citation was correct and it is affirmed. SERVICE AND PROGRAM VIOLATIONS
7. Violation: The license holder did not offer services as required.
The license holder failed to maintain a family and social history in P1, P2, and P3’s records that were updated annually.
Rule Violated: Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9710, subpart 7.
Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you were previously found in violation of this same subpart.
Corrective Action Required: Within 30 days of receiving this order, you must maintain family and social histories in P1, P2, and P3’s records. On an ongoing basis you must maintain compliance as required in this subpart.
Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9710, subpart 7. The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the license holder failed to maintain a family and social history for P1, P2, and P3’s records that was updated annually, as required by Minnesota Rules, part 9555.9710, subpart 7. Therefore, this citation was correct and it is affirmed. POLICY AND PROCEDURES VIOLATIONS
8. Violation: The license holder did not establish a written program abuse prevention plan (PAPP) as required.
The license holder failed to establish a written PAPP, including:
· an assessment of the population, including:
o the need for specialized programs of care for clients; and
o the knowledge a license holder may have regarding previous abuse that is relevant to minimizing risk of abuse for clients; and
· an assessment of the environment, including:
o the type of internal programming; and
o the program’s staffing patterns.
Statute Violated: Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 2, paragraph (a). Repeat Violation: In a Correction Order that DHS issued on December 12, 2022, you were previously found in violation of this same subdivision. Your request for reconsideration: The license holder stated that it was requesting reconsideration of the determination that it violated Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 2(a). The license holder stated generally that it has been working to correct the violations.
DHS’ response: The license holder did not explain why it believes it was not responsible for this violation or submit any documentation showing that the citation was incorrect. According to the license holder’s documentation that DHS reviewed at the time of the licensing visit, the license holder did not meet all of the requirements for the PAPP, as required by Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.65, subdivision 2(a). Therefore, this citation was correct and it is affirmed.
B. RECONSIDERATION OF CONDITIONAL LICENSE
Under Minnesota Statutes, section 245A.06, subdivision 1, when issuing a conditional license, the Commissioner must consider the nature, chronicity, or severity of the violation of the law or rule and the effect of the violation on the health, safety, or rights of persons served by the program. In the request for reconsideration, the license holder requested to vacate the Order of Conditional License. The license holder stated that it has worked extensively to correct the violations and it has overhauled its operations to streamline its policies and procedures to make sure it remains in compliance. The license holder described some of the changes it has made to meet the requirements in the Order of Conditional License, including streamlining its participant application and implementing a new intake procedure. As explained above in section A, the seven licensing violations cited in the Order of Conditional License that the license holder challenged on reconsideration are affirmed. The citation that the license holder did not challenge is also affirmed. All eight of the licensing violations included in the Order of Conditional License were repeat violations. The Commissioner appreciates that the license holder has described the efforts it has made to correct the violations and to ensure its compliance with licensing statutes and rules in the future. However, the Commissioner has considered the nature, chronicity, and severity of the licensing violations and determined that a conditional license is warranted. Based on the following factors, the Commissioner has determined that the record supports the Order of Conditional License. · Violations affecting the health, safety, or rights of participants
Six citations in the Order of Conditional License affect the health, safety, and rights of persons served by the program. The violations include: failure to meet the requirements for individual abuse prevention plans; failure to maintain participants’ written records; failure to complete initial service planning; failure to develop a written plan of care; failure to offer social services; and failure to establish a written program abuse prevention plan, as required. The violations affecting the health, safety, or rights of individuals served by the program alone warrant a conditional license. · Failure to maintain accurate documentation
All eight of the citations in the Order of Conditional License involved the license holder’s failure to maintain accurate documentation. These violations included: failure to meet the requirements for individual abuse prevention plans; failure to maintain participants’ written records; failure to complete initial service planning; failure to develop a written plan of care; failure to maintain personnel records as required; failure to provide training to mandated reporters; failure to offer social services; and failure to establish a written program abuse prevention plan, as required. The license holder’s failure to maintain accurate documentation is serious. DHS must be able to review the license holder’s documentation in order to ensure that it is meeting the requirements of the applicable laws and rules and providing the required services to persons served by the program. By failing to maintain accurate documentation in participant, staff, and consultant records, it is difficult for DHS to determine whether the license holder is meeting applicable requirements, providing required services, and protecting the health, safety, and rights of participants. The number of violations related to documentation indicate that the license holder has a widespread issue maintaining accurate and complete documentation. As a result, the license holder requires increased supervision from DHS to ensure compliance with applicable laws and rules. These violations alone warrant a conditional license, given the widespread documentation issue and that many of the violations affect the health, safety, or rights of individuals served by the program. · A pattern of non-compliance
The license holder received its license on February 1, 2019. On December 12, 2022, DHS issued a correction order containing 11 violations to the license holder following a licensing review on December 7, 2022. In the correction order, DHS notified the license holder that certain citations were required to be corrected immediately and other citations were required to be corrected within 30 days of the license holder’s receipt of the order. On February 28, 2023, DHS licensors conducted a follow-up licensing review. On March 15, 2023, DHS issued the Order of Conditional License, which contained eight violations, all of which were repeat violations from the December 12, 2022 correction order. The license holder’s history of licensing violations in a relatively short period of time, and the number of repeat violations, demonstrates that the license holder has a history of noncompliance with licensing statutes and rules.
Based on the specific factors above, an Order of Conditional License is warranted to ensure that the license holder understands the relevant licensing requirements and is able to come fully into compliance. Due to the need to monitor the license holder for compliance with applicable licensing laws and rules, and to ensure the health and safety of individuals served by the program, the Commissioner affirms the Order of Conditional License. The period of the conditional license is two years, beginning on October 27, 2023, which is the date of this reconsideration decision. Because the terms of your conditional license were stayed pending a decision on your request for reconsideration, the terms of the conditional license begin from the date of receipt of this letter. C. TERMS OF THE CONDITIONAL LICENSE In addition to the adult day care licensing rules and statutes, you are required to comply with the following terms: 1. Within 15 days of receiving this order, you must notify current persons receiving services, all parties who refer persons to the program, and all payer sources of the conditional status of your license. The notification must be approved by DHS Licensing prior to being sent to persons receiving services and all other parties. Therefore, the draft notice must be submitted to DHS for approval within 10 days of receiving this order. The notification must specify the length of time of the conditional status of your license, the reasons your license was made conditional, and it must include either a copy of the Order of Conditional License or an offer to provide a copy of the order upon request.
While the license is on conditional status, you must notify new persons receiving services, referral sources, and payer sources that the license is on conditional status before they begin receiving adult day care services. The notification to new persons receiving services must specify the length of time of the conditional status of the license, the reasons the license was made conditional, and it must include either a copy of the Order of Conditional License or an offer to provide a copy of the order upon request.
Within 30 days of receiving this order, you must submit to the DHS Licensing Division a list of the individuals and parties that received the notice. Additionally, while the license is on conditional status, you must maintain documentation of the names of individuals you’ve provided the notification to and the date the individual was provided the notification.
2. Within 30 days of receiving this order, you must: · develop a quality assurance audit tool to ensure personnel records include all required documentation and training; · develop a quality assurance audit tool to ensure participant records include all required information; and · submit the quality assurance audit tools to your DHS licensor for approval.
3. Within 30 days of receiving approval of your quality assurance audit tools from your DHS licensor, you must complete an audit of all participant and personnel records using the approved quality assurance audit tool. Additionally, you must submit the date to your DHS licensor that all participant and personnel records will be brought into compliance based on the results of your audit.
4. You may not admit new participants to your program from the date of this order until you have successfully demonstrated to DHS compliance with the terms of the conditional license and have maintained substantial compliance with all licensing standards. At a minimum, you may not admit new participants to your program for a period of six months from the date of this conditional license. Prior to admitting any new participant during the duration of the conditional license, you must notify your licensor of the name and admission date of the new participant.
Submissions required as part of a corrective action ordered must be sent to your Licensor:
1. by secure email at: Desiree.B.Tiller@state.mn.us; or
2. send fax to:
651-431-7673
ATTN: Desiree Tiller
D. RIGHT TO APPEAL TO THE MINNESOTA COURT OF APPEALS
This is a final agency decision and is subject to further review only by the Minnesota Court of Appeals. Please note that there are time limits for seeking review by the Minnesota Court of Appeals. See Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 606 and Minnesota Rules of Civil Appellate Procedure, Rule 115. If you have any questions regarding the Order of Conditional License, please contact Brittany Raddatz, HCBS Supervisor, at 651-431-6591.
Sincerely, 
Morgan Bianco, Attorney
Legal Counsel’s Office
Office of Inspector General
PO Box 64242 • Saint Paul, Minnesota • 55164-0242 • An Equal Opportunity and Veteran Friendly Employer https://mn.gov/dhs/general-public/licensing/
|