|

MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATION MEMORANDUM
Office of Inspector General, Licensing Division
Public Information
Minnesota Statutes, section 626.557, subdivision 1 states, “The legislature declares that the public policy of this state is to protect adults who, because of physical or mental disability or dependency on institutional services, are particularly vulnerable to maltreatment.”
Report Number: 202608089 | Date Issued: September 28, 2926 |
Name and Address of Facility Investigated: Community Living Options-Willow
3764 Mallard Road
Brook Park, MN 55007
Community Living Options
26022 Main St.
Zimmerman, MN 55398 | Disposition: Substantiated as to neglect of a vulnerable adult by a staff person. |
License Number and Program Type:
1110168-H_CRS (Home and Community-Based Services-Community Residential Setting)
1070470-HCBS (Home and Community-Based Services)
Investigator(s):
Scott Brandt
Minnesota Department of Human Services
Office of Inspector General
Licensing Division
PO Box 64242
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55164-0242
Suspected Maltreatment Reported:
It was reported that while a staff person (SP) provided transportation to a vulnerable adult (VA) and a facility staff person (P1), the SP drove erratically, struck a mailbox, damaged a mirror on the facility’s vehicle, and appeared to be under the influence of alcohol.
Date of Incident(s): August 12, 2026
Nature of Alleged Maltreatment Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 626.557, subdivision 9c, paragraph (b), and Minnesota Statutes, section 626.5572, subdivision 15, and subdivision 17, paragraph (a):
The failure or omission by a caregiver to supply a vulnerable adult with care or services, including but not limited to food, clothing, shelter, health care, or supervision which is reasonable and necessary to obtain or maintain the vulnerable adult's physical or mental health or safety, considering the physical and mental capacity or dysfunction of the vulnerable adult and which is not the result of an accident or therapeutic conduct.
Summary of Findings: Pertinent information was obtained during a site visit conducted on August 24, 2026; from documentation at the facility; and through six interviews conducted with the VA, the SP, a facility staff person (P1), and three management staff persons (P2-P4). A community person (CP) provided a written statement regarding the incident.
The VA’s Supports and Outcomes Methods plan showed that the VA enjoyed listening to music, going for walks, and riding his/her bike. The VA’s Assessment Summary showed that the VA had a mild developmental disability. Staff assisted the VA with completion of activities of daily living and accessing the community.
P1 provided the following information:
· Although P1 was not certain of the date, s/he worked from 3-10 p.m. with the SP on the date of the incident. When the SP and P1 began working, P1 noted that the SP seemed “fine,” but had a “migraine” headache. P1 did not note anything unusual regarding the SP’s mobility or speech.
· At about 6:30 p.m., the SP moved his/her personal vehicle from the driveway. About 30 seconds later, P1, the SP, and the VA left the facility to go on a ride in the facility van. The SP drove, P1 sat in the front passenger seat, and the VA sat in the middle seat, behind the SP and P1. Before leaving, the SP drank something from a “water bottle” inside the facility, but P1 could not see what was in the bottle.
· Shortly after leaving the facility, the SP began “swerving” onto the right shoulder and then back into the driving lane. While the SP swerved onto the right shoulder, the SP hit a mailbox. The SP crossed the center line and swerved into the other lane. P1 described the SP as driving “super-fast” (65-70 miles per hour in a 55 mile per hour zone) or “very slow” (30 miles per hour). After stopping the vehicle, the SP called P2 and stated that “something flew into the road” and damaged a mirror on the vehicle. P1 did not see anything fly from the road, but saw the SP hit the mailbox. P1 did not correct the SP and tell him/her that s/he hit a mailbox or make comments about the SP’s driving because P1 did not want to further “distract” the SP. While the SP was talking to P2, the SP’s speech seemed “normal.” When the SP finished talking to P2, the SP continued driving and his/her concerning driving patterns continued. Then, P1 noticed that the SP’s words began “slurring.”
· The SP drove to a tobacco store. The SP got out of the vehicle and went into the store. P1 called P2 because the SP’s “driving was really bad,” P1 was “scared” of the SP’s driving because the SP was driving “erratically,” the SP appeared to be under the influence of alcohol because P1 smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath, and P1 was concerned that the SP would continue driving after leaving the tobacco store. While P1 talked to P2, P1 assisted the VA, who was “pretty scared,” with getting out of the vehicle. P2 told P1 that s/he would come to the tobacco store. When the SP came out of the store about three minutes later, P1 again noticed that the SP’s breath smelled like “alcohol.” P1 told the SP that s/he did not feel “safe” riding with the SP because the SP’s driving was “really bad.” The SP said, “I’m fine.” The SP dropped his/her “vape” on the ground and the SP fell toward P1 and P1 and the VA had to “catch” the SP from falling on the ground. When that happened, P1 smelled “a very strong smell that smelled like alcohol.” P1 asked the SP if s/he needed medical attention and the SP said, “No, I don’t want to get fired.” When the SP asked P1 if s/he would drive back to the facility, P1 told the SP that s/he was unable to drive and that s/he had called P2 and P2 was coming to the tobacco store.
· When P2 and P3 arrived (P2 picked up P3 prior to arriving) at the tobacco store, P1 told them that the SP hit a mailbox while driving, but the SP denied doing so. The SP was driven home by someone but P1 did not remember by who.
· P1 was aware that the SP took medication for a migraine headache but did not know what the SP took or when s/he took it. P1 did not see the SP drink anything during the drive.
The VA provided limited information, but stated that the SP hit the mailbox, drove from side to side on the road, and that the VA was “scared” of the SP’s driving.
The website, www.mapquest, showed that the distance between the facility and the tobacco store was 15 miles.
The CP, who worked at the tobacco store, provided a written statement that stated, “I was working when your employee came in my store on Thursday evening. [S/he] was visibly intoxicated, stumbling over and seemingly nodding off standing in the store. I asked [him/her] multiple times if [s/he] was ok[ay] and asked if [s/he] was driving. [S/he] said no.”
P4 stated that when s/he was at the tobacco store, the CP came outside and asked if the SP was a staff person and P4 said, “Yes.” The CP told P4 that when the SP was in the store, the SP was “drunk.”
P2 provided the following information:
· On August 12, 2026, the SP called P2 and said that something “flew up in the road and hit the mirror in the van.” P2 provided guidance to the SP about completing reports when s/he returned to the facility. At the time, P2 did not have concerns about the SP’s speech.
· About 10 to 15 minutes later, P2 received a call from P1, who told P2 that s/he was not going to get back in the vehicle with the SP because P1 felt “unsafe.” P1 also stated the SP was “barely stopping at stop signs,” was “slurring” his/her words, and the SP hit the mailbox with the van. When the SP came out of the tobacco store, P1 put the phone on speakerphone and P2 also talked to the SP. When P2 asked the SP if s/he needed medical attention, the SP said, “No, I’m fucking fine.” P2 told the SP and P1 to not go anywhere because P2 was coming to the tobacco store.
· After the call from P1, P2 called P3 and asked him/her to pick up P2 and they went to the tobacco store together. When they got to the store about an hour later, the SP told P2 that s/he was fine with driving back to the facility, but P2 told the SP that s/he would not be driving the vehicle. P2 noted that the SP’s face was “really flushed” and that s/he was “slurring” his/her words. P2 “slightly” smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath. The SP denied hitting the mailbox. P2 went into the tobacco store and the CP told P2 that s/he was “about to call the police” because of the SP’s conduct. (Investigator’s note: law enforcement was not called). P2 called P4 and P4 stated that s/he would also go to the tobacco store.
· P2 previously had not smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath, never saw the SP under the influence of alcohol, and did not have concerns related to the SP’s work performance.
P3 provided the following information:
· At about 6 p.m. on August 12, 2026, P3 received a phone call from P2. P2 asked P3 if s/he would pick up P2 and go to the tobacco store which s/he did. When P3 and P2 arrived at the tobacco store, they met P4. While other staff talked with the SP, P3 sat in the vehicle with the VA.
· When it was determined that P3 would take the SP home, so s/he did. Before P3 left the tobacco store to take the SP home, P3 noted that the SP’s mobility was “pretty good.” During the drive, the SP was “pretty emotional” and stated that s/he “didn’t do anything wrong.” The SP only looked forward and did not make eye contact with P3. P3 believed that s/he smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath but was not certain because P3 had an air freshener in his/her vehicle. P3 described the SP as being “emotional.”
P4 said that when s/he got to the tobacco store at about 7 p.m. on August 12, 2026, the SP was “staggering” and P4 smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath. P4 also noted that the SP’s eyes were “really red” and “dilated,” and that his/her words were “slurred.” When P4 asked the SP if s/he had a medical condition or was on medications that could alter his/her actions, the SP said, “No.”
Photographs, taken by P4, on August 12, 2026, showed damage to the mirror on the right side of the vehicle.
The facility had a drug and alcohol policy that stated that “drug and alcohol use is highly detrimental to the safety and productivity of employees in the workplace. No employee maybe under the influence of any illicit drug, alcohol, THC while in the workplace, while on duty, or while operating a vehicle or equipment owned or leased by the company.” The policy also stated, “drug or alcohol testing may be required when there is a reasonable suspicion that an individual is currently abusing a drug or alcohol, is under the influence of drugs or alcohol while on duty” and “failure to complete the testing or upon receiving positive test results are cause for disciplinary action, up to and including termination.” The SP was trained on the policy on January 28, 2026.
The SP had an assessment completed, by phone, on August 19, 2026, that stated, “My employer wanted me to get an assessment done. I don’t know if it’s because they had issues in the past with other people. I was driving a [facility] van and hit a mailbox on accident. I don’t know if they assume I was drinking or what.” The report stated that the SP’s “LDU [last date of use]” was on August 17, 2026, and “prior to this, it was on July 29, 2026.” One of the questions asked was, “Do you use greater amounts of alcohol/other drugs to feel intoxicated or achieve the desired effects.” The SP responded, “No.”
The SP provided the following information:
· The day of the incident, while driving the vehicle with P1 and the VA as passengers, the SP “accidently” hit the mailbox. When this investigator asked the SP why s/he denied hitting the mailbox when s/he talked to management, the SP did not provide an answer.
· The SP denied swerving, denied driving at excessive or low speeds, denied almost falling on the ground, and denied being under the influence of alcohol, or any other substance, while driving.
· The SP did not have a medical condition or take any medications that could be interpreted as being under the influence of alcohol.
The facility’s training records showed that all staff persons interviewed for this investigation were trained on the VA’s care plans and the Reporting of Maltreatment of Vulnerable Adults Act prior to August 12, 2026.
Conclusion:
A. Maltreatment:
At about 6 p.m. on August 12, 2026, the SP drove the facility van, for about 15 miles, with P1 and the VA as passengers. Shortly after the SP began driving, P1 noted that the SP was swerving, driving out of the driving lane, driving slowly and/or excessively fast, and hit a mailbox, which caused damage to the facility’s vehicle. Shortly after hitting the mailbox, the SP began “slurring” his/her words. The SP drove to a tobacco shop and when the SP got out of the vehicle and went into the store, P1 called P2 because the SP’s “driving was really bad,” P1 was “scared,” the SP was driving “erratically,” and the SP appeared to be under the influence of alcohol because P1 smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath. The VA stated that the SP hit the mailbox, drove from side to side on the road, and that the VA was “scared” of the SP’s driving.
When P2-P4 got to the tobacco store, they provided information that the SP appeared to be under the influence of alcohol. P2 said that the SP was “slurring” his/her words and P2 “slightly” smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath. P3 drove the SP home and believed that s/he smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath but was not certain because P3 used an air freshener in his/her vehicle. P4 said that the SP was “staggering” and P4 smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath. When P4 asked the SP if s/he had a medical condition or was on medications that could alter his/her actions, the SP said, “No.” The CP provided a written statement that the SP was “visibly intoxicated, stumbling over and seemingly nodding off standing in the store.” P4 stated that when s/he was at the tobacco store, the CP came outside and asked if the SP was a staff person and P4 said, “Yes.” The CP told P4 that when the SP was in the store, the SP was “drunk.”
The SP stated that s/he “accidently” hit the mailbox, but denied swerving, denied driving at excessive or low speeds, and denied being under the influence of alcohol, or any other substance, while driving.
Although the SP denied being under the influence of a substance while driving and the VA was not harmed, given the SP’s behavior was consistently described by the CP, P1, P2, P3, and P4 as being under the influence of a substance, that P1, P2, P3, and P4 each stated they smelled alcohol on the SP’s breath to varying degrees, that the VA and P1 provided consistent information that the SP’s driving was unsafe that day, and that driving while under the influence of a substance posed a serious risk of harm to the VA’s health and safety, there was a preponderance of the evidence that the SP failed to provide reasonable and necessary care and services to the VA.
It was determined that neglect occurred (the failure or omission by a caregiver to supply a vulnerable adult with care or services, including but not limited to food, clothing, shelter, health care, or supervision which is reasonable and necessary to obtain or maintain the vulnerable adult's physical or mental health or safety, considering the physical and mental capacity or dysfunction of the vulnerable adult and which is not the result of an accident or therapeutic conduct).
B. Responsibility pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 626.557, subdivision 9c, paragraph (c):
When determining whether the facility or individual is the responsible party for substantiated maltreatment or whether both the facility and the individual are responsible for substantiated maltreatment, the lead agency shall consider at least the following mitigating factors:
(1) whether the actions of the facility or the individual caregivers were in accordance with, and followed the terms of, an erroneous physician order, prescription, resident care plan, or directive. This is not a mitigating factor when the facility or caregiver is responsible for the issuance of the erroneous order, prescription, plan, or directive or knows or should have known of the errors and took no reasonable measures to correct the defect before administering care;
(2) the comparative responsibility between the facility, other caregivers, and requirements placed upon the employee, including but not limited to, the facility’s compliance with related regulatory standards and factors such as the adequacy of facility policies and procedures, the adequacy of facility training, the adequacy of an individual’s participation in the training, the adequacy of caregiver supervision, the adequacy of facility staffing levels, and a consideration of the scope of the individual employee’s authority; and
(3) whether the facility or individual followed professional standards in exercising professional judgment.
Given that the SP was trained on the facility’s drug and alcohol policy and the Reporting of Maltreatment of Vulnerable Adults Act, the SP was responsible for maltreatment of the VA.
C. Recurring and/or Serious Maltreatment:
The Office of Inspector General is required to evaluate whether substantiated maltreatment by an individual meets the statutory criteria to be determined as “recurring or serious.” Individuals determined to be responsible for recurring or serious maltreatment are disqualified from providing direct contact services.
Minnesota Statutes, section 245C.02, subdivision 16, states:
“Recurring maltreatment” means more than one incident of maltreatment for which there is a preponderance of evidence that maltreatment occurred and that the subject was responsible for the maltreatment.
Minnesota Statutes, section 245C.02, subdivision 18, states:
"Serious maltreatment" means sexual abuse, maltreatment resulting in death, neglect resulting in serious injury which reasonably requires the care of a physician whether or not the care of a physician was sought, abuse resulting in serious injury, or financial exploitation of a vulnerable adult if the value of the funds or property is $1,000 or greater. For purposes of this definition, "care of a physician" is treatment received or ordered by a physician, physician assistant, or nurse practitioner, but does not include diagnostic testing, assessment, or observation; the application of, recommendation to use, or prescription solely for a remedy that is available over the counter without a prescription; or a prescription solely for a topical antibiotic to treat burns when there is no follow-up appointment. For purposes of this definition, "abuse resulting in serious injury" means: bruises, bites, skin laceration, or tissue damage; fractures; dislocations; evidence of internal injuries; head injuries with loss of consciousness; extensive second-degree or third-degree burns and other burns for which complications are present; extensive second-degree or third-degree frostbite and other frostbite for which complications are present; irreversible mobility or avulsion of teeth; injuries to the eyes; ingestion of foreign substances and objects that are harmful; near drowning; and heat exhaustion or sunstroke. Serious maltreatment includes neglect when it results in criminal sexual conduct against a child or vulnerable adult.
It was determined that the substantiated neglect for which the SP was responsible did not meet statutory criteria to be determined as recurring or serious because it was a single incident and the VA did not sustain an injury.
Action Taken by Facility:
The facility completed an Incident Report and Internal Review which showed that policies and procedures were adequate, followed, and that staff would be retrained on the drug and alcohol policy.
Action Taken by Department of Human Services, Office of Inspector General:
The SP was not disqualified from providing direct care services as a result of the maltreatment determination in this report. However, the SP was notified by the Office of Inspector General that any further substantiated act of maltreatment, whether or not the act meets the criteria for “serious,” will automatically meet the criteria for “recurring” and will result in the disqualification of the SP. The determination that the SP was responsible for maltreatment is subject to appeal.
PO Box 64242 • Saint Paul, Minnesota • 55164-0242 • An Equal Opportunity and Veteran Friendly Employer https://mn.gov/dhs/general-public/licensing/
|