Minnesota Minnesota

Community-Based Services Manual (CBSM)

Community-Based Services Manual (CBSM)


Appeals process

Page posted: 11/13/17

Page reviewed: 11/12/26

Page updated: 11/12/26

Legal authority

42 C.F.R. 431.200 to 431.250, Minn. Stat. §256.045, Minn. Stat. §256.0451, Minn. Stat. §256B.0911, subd. 3(a), Minn. R. 9505.0125

Overview

As a supplement to CBSM – Appeals, this page provides step-by-step information about the appeals process for both the person and the applicable county or Tribal Nation.

Process

The process for long-term services and supports (LTSS) includes the following steps:

1. The county/Tribal Nation notifies the person about a change to their services and supports through a notice of action.

2. The person files an appeal in response to the notice of action.

3. The DHS Appeals Division requests an appeal summary from the responsible agency.

4. The county/Tribal Nation continues services at the previous level, pending the appeal’s outcome (unless the appellant requests not to have a continuation of benefits).

5. The county/Tribal Nation and appellant may resolve the appeal before the fair hearing.

6. The county/Tribal Nation completes and submits the appeal summary.

7. The DHS Appeals Division schedules a hearing.

8. The DHS Appeals Division issues a decision.

9. The county/Tribal Nation implements the decision.

10. The Appellant or county/Tribal Nation may request reconsideration from the DHS Appeals Division.

These steps generally happen in chronological order, but some steps may happen at the same time. The following sections describe these steps in detail.

Notice of action

The county/Tribal Nation must send the person a notice of action when they change the person’s services and supports. That notice includes information about why they made the decision and how to file an appeal.

For information about when a notice of action is required, refer to CBSM – Notice of action.

Person files an appeal in response to the notice of action

If the person decides to appeal, they must submit a written request to the county/Tribal Nation or the DHS Appeals Division.

The person may use Appeal to State Agency, DHS-0033 to submit their appeal request.

If the person sends their request to the county/Tribal Nation, the county/Tribal Nation must forward the request to the DHS Appeals Division as soon as possible.

Timeframe

The person must submit the written request within 30 calendar days of when they received the notice of action. They may submit the request within 90 calendar days if they show a good reason for delay beyond the 30-day timeframe.

DHS Appeals Division requests an appeal summary from a county/Tribal Nation

When the person requests an appeal, the DHS Appeals Division will ask the agency whose action is being appealed (e.g., lead agency, DHS Disability Services Division) to complete an appeal summary. This request acts as notice to the agency that the person filed an appeal.

When the appeal is related to an action taken by an assessor or case manager, the result of an assessment or another action taken by the county/Tribal Nation, the county/Tribal Nation is responsible to complete the appeal summary.

For instructions about how to complete and submit the appeal summary, refer to the section below about the appeal summary on this page.

Receiving a request for an appeal summary in error

The county/Tribal Nation follows this guidance if they receive a request for an appeal summary from the DHS Appeals Division about either of the following situations.

Non-waiver home health services or home care nursing

For home health services (e.g., skilled nursing visits, home health aide visits) or home care nursing for an appellant who is not on a waiver, the county/Tribal Nation should notify both the Appeals Division at Appeals.Paralegal.DHS@state.mn.us and the human services judge that the DHS Disability Services Division must complete the appeal summary. This also applies to appeals of reduction to Community First Services and Supports (CFSS) services due to an authorization for home care nursing. The DHS Appeals Division will resend the summary request to the appropriate entity.

Managed care organizations (MCOs)

For service determinations made by an MCO, the county or Tribal Nation should notify both the Appeals Division at Appeals.Paralegal.DHS@state.mn.us and the human services judge that the MCO must complete the appeal summary. The DHS Appeals Division will resend the summary request to the appropriate entity.

County/Tribal Nation responsibility to continue services at previous level, pending the appeal’s outcome

When the person requests an appeal, they have the right to keep their benefits the same as they were before the county/Tribal Nation’s notice of action. This is true until the human services judge makes a final decision.

Exception: When a person appeals an involuntary exit from consumer directed community supports (CDCS), the lead agency ends the authorization for financial management services (FMS), and the person is not able to remain on CDCS during the appeal.

The responsibility and required timeframes for continuing services differ depending on the action the person appeals.

Personal care assistance (PCA) and Community First Services and Supports (CFSS)

Type B service agreements

If the person appeals an action related to PCA/CFSS or home care services authorized on a type B service agreement and does so within the required timeframe (described above), DHS automatically continues their services unless the appellant requests services to end. The county/Tribal Nation does not need to take action.

PCA/CFSS services through a waiver or Alternative Care (AC)

If the person appeals an action related to PCA/CFSS services authorized through a waiver or AC and does so within the required timeframe (described above), PCA/CFSS services should continue at the previous level, unless the person requests their services to end. The county/Tribal Nation is responsible to continue PCA/CFSS services authorized through a waiver or AC.

CDCS services

If the person appeals an action that impacts CDCS budgets and chooses to continue benefits, the county/Tribal Nation is responsible to continue CDCS services as outlined in the last approved CDCS community support plan.

All other services

If the person appeals an action related to other services, they must request continuation of services within 10 days of receiving the notice of action. The county/Tribal Nation needs to take action to continue the person’s benefits at the previous level. The county/Tribal Nation is responsible to continue all services authorized through a waiver, AC or Essential Community Supports (ECS).

County/Tribal Nation and appellant may resolve the appeal before fair hearing

Before the fair hearing, the county/Tribal Nation may contact the appellant to discuss the dispute they raised in the appeal request. In some cases, the county/Tribal Nation and appellant may resolve the dispute with additional communication.

If the county/Tribal Nation and the appellant are able to resolve the dispute before the fair hearing, the county/Tribal Nation should advise the appellant to withdraw their appeal. The appellant can either:

  • · Complete Cancel Appeal to State Agency, DHS-8334.
  • · Call the DHS Appeals Division directly at 651-431-3600.
  • If the county/Tribal Nation does not receive a decision from the judge that the appeal was withdrawn, the county/Tribal Nation completes the appeal summary to inform the appellant and the human services judge of the resolution.

    County/Tribal Nation completes and submits the appeal summary

    The person who took the action on behalf of the county/Tribal Nation (e.g., certified assessor, case manager) is responsible to complete the appeal summary using Appeal Summary for LTSS, DHS-6807 (PDF), State Agency Appeals Summary, DHS-0035 or an alternative narrative format. If using a narrative format, refer to DHS-0035 for information to include.

    Requirements

    The appeal summary must provide the appellant and human services judge with:

  • · Description of the action the person is appealing in detail.
  • · Reason the county/Tribal Nation took the action.
  • Considerations

    While completing the appeal summary, consider the following:

  • · The appeal summary must sufficiently explain to the appellant and human services judge why the county/Tribal Nation took the action. The county/Tribal Nation may need to attach additional documentation.
  • · Attach any additional documentation that supports the action taken (e.g., support plan, diagnostic evaluations, assessment summary).
  • For questions about what to include in the appeal summary or for technical assistance, email DHS.CCAappeals@state.mn.us.

    Submission

    The county/Tribal Nation must submit the appeal summary and any supporting documentation at least three days before the hearing.

    If using DHS-6807 or an alternative narrative format, the county/Tribal Nation emails the document to Appeals.Paralegal.DHS@state.mn.us.

    If using DHS-0035, the county/Tribal Nation follows the instructions on the form to submit it. After submission, the county/Tribal Nation receives a PDF copy of DHS-0035 to save, print and send to the appellant.

    The county/Tribal Nation must send the completed appeal summary and any supporting documentation at least three days before the hearing to:

  • · Appellant and their representative(s), if applicable.
  • · DHS Aging and Adult Services and Disability Services divisions at DHS.CCAappeals@state.mn.us.
  • The county/Tribal Nation should notify the human services judge of their intent to participate in the hearing. If participating in the hearing, the county/Tribal Nation should provide a contact phone number.

    When the county/Tribal Nation needs to submit paperwork after they have submitted the appeal summary, they can use DHS Appeal Party Document Submission, DHS-8272, email the paralegal assigned to the docket directly or email Appeals.Paralegal.DHS@state.mn.us.

    DHS Appeals Division schedules a hearing

    The DHS Appeals Division will schedule the hearing. The hearing typically takes place via phone, but it could also take place in person or via videoconference if requested by the appellant. The DHS Appeals Division will notify the county/Tribal Nation and appellant of the hearing date, time, location and additional guidance about attending the hearing.

    The hearing date, time and location is subject to change to permit flexibility.

    Timeframe

    The DHS Appeals Division will send the notice of hearing after receiving the appeal request.

    What to expect at the hearing

    The hearing is a semi-formal process. All participants are sworn in, and the human services judge directs the participants when to respond.

    The DHS Appeals Division:

  • · Will record the hearing.
  • · Will prepare a transcript only if the appellant appeals the final decision to the district court.
  • · May keep the hearing records open to allow the parties to submit relevant evidence.
  • DHS Appeals Division issues a decision

    Following the hearing, the human services judge recommends a decision and sends it to the chief appeals judge, who acts on behalf of the DHS commissioner. The chief human services judge can:

  • · Accept the recommended decision.
  • · Revise the recommended decision.
  • · Reject the recommended decision and issue their own decision.
  • The chief human services judge issues the final decision within 90 days of the appeal request. This timeline may be longer due to continuances or to allow time for each side to submit and review additional evidence after the hearing.

    The DHS Appeals Division sends the final decision to the appellant and all other involved parties, such as:

  • · Appellant’s representative.
  • · County/Tribal Nation staff.
  • · MCO staff.
  • · DHS Aging and Adult Services or Disability Services division staff.
  • The decision typically will do one of the following:

  • · Affirm the county/Tribal Nation’s action (i.e., keep the outcome of the action the same).
  • · Reverse the county/Tribal Nation’s action (i.e., change the outcome).
  • · Dismiss the appeal request.
  • · Remand the appeal back to the agency who took the action (i.e., send back to the agency for action). Typically, the human services judge includes instructions for additional action.
  • If the county/Tribal Nation receives a remanded appeal or has questions about the decision, email DHS.CCAAppeals@state.mn.us.

    County/Tribal Nation implements the decision

    As soon as possible, the county/Tribal Nation must either:

  • · Implement the final decision
  • · Request a reconsideration within 30 days of the decision. For instructions, refer to the reconsideration section below.
  • Updating the person’s support plan and service agreement

    If changes to the person’s support plan and service agreement are necessary to implement the final decision, the county/Tribal Nation must:

  • · Update the support plan.
  • · Enter changes for waiver/AC/ECS service agreements and indicate that the change is a result of the appeal decision on the comment screen in MMIS.
  • DHS will enter changes for home care and CFSS service agreements (i.e., type B) in MMIS.

    Technical assistance

    Contact DHS.CCAAppeals@state.mn.us via secure email for technical assistance implementing decisions regarding assessment results, CDCS budget changes or any difficulties making the necessary changes to a service agreement. For instructions about secure emails, refer to CBSM – How to exchange private and protected information with DHS.

    Reconsideration of final appeal decision

    If the appellant or county/Tribal Nation disagrees with the chief human services judge’s final decision, either party may request reconsideration from the DHS Appeals Division. The appellant may appeal the final decision in district court.

    Note: As soon as possible, the county/Tribal Nation must implement the decision even if the appellant requests a reconsideration or is appealing to a district court.

    Timeframe

    The appellant or county/Tribal Nation must request reconsideration within 30 calendar days of when the chief human services judge issues the final decision. The DHS Appeals Division will make a determination to grant or deny reconsideration.

    If the DHS Appeals Division chooses to reconsider the decision, it will provide each party an opportunity to submit additional information relevant to the reconsideration. They must submit this information within 10 business days of the request. The DHS Appeals Division will make the final determination to review the request.

    Process

    To request reconsideration, email the paralegal assigned to the docket directly or email Appeals.Paralegal.DHS@state.mn.us and include the reason for the request.

    For technical assistance for formal reconsideration requests, email DHS.CCAAppeals@state.mn.us.

    As the appellant or county/Tribal Nation decides if they want to request reconsideration, consider that the DHS Appeals Division director:

  • · May agree to reconsider the decision if it appears the decision contains a significant legal or factual error.
  • · Cannot reconsider a decision once it has been appealed to the district court.
  • Additional resources

    CBSM – Appeals
    CBSM – How to exchange private and protected information with DHS
    CBSM – Notice of action
    DHS – Appeals
    DHS Appeal Party Document Submission, DHS-8272
    State Agency Appeals Summary, DHS-0035 (PDF)
    Appeal Summary for LTSS, DHS-6807 (PDF)

    Report this page